Gear › Pans › 14-month test

I Spent $8,477 Testing 100 Pans For 14 Months. Nonstick, Ceramic, Stainless, Cast Iron, Titanium. Only 1 Is Still On My Stove.

Every pan you've been told to buy. Same 7 questions, same eggs, same abuse. One winner, and it's not the one your grandma swears by.

Wade Merritt in his restaurant kitchen with the pans he tested

By Wade MerrittOwner, Merritt's Steakhouse, Fort Worth · Updated October 2026 · 6 min read

The short version

Nonstickexpires3.1

Ceramicexpires faster3.4

"Titanium" brandsmostly fake≤4.6

Stainlesslasts, sticks6.1

Cast ironlasts, 8 lbs6.6

The one that passedstill on my stove9.4

Skip to the one that passed

31 years behind a grill. Abusing pans is my job.

Two years ago my daughter sent me a video of black flakes in her eggs. Coating. She asked what to buy instead. Everybody had an answer. Ceramic. Stainless. Cast iron. Titanium.

I didn't trust any of them. So I bought them all. 100 pans, $8,477, 14 months of 500°F brisket fat, wine braises, steel wool and the dishwasher. Plus a magnet and a hacksaw.

Receipts and shipping boxes totalling $8,477

The 6 tests every pan had to survive

PriceWhat it costs, and how often you buy it again.
What touches your foodCoating, seasoning or bare metal. Hacksaw on one of each.
Does it stick?Day one, and month three.
How long it lastsMy kitchen, plus 400 customer reviews.
Weight and careOn a scale, and what it needs from you every night.
Aftertaste or flakesMetallic tang, black flecks, anything that shouldn't be in the food.

1 of 5 · Tested 14 months

Nonstick: a pan with an expiry date

Nonstick pan after 7 months, coating worn and eggs stuck

The pan you already own. Probably your third one. $20 supermarket or $800 "hybrid" with a celebrity chef on the box. Same film underneath.

Price: $20 to $60 a pan. Hybrid sets: customers report $699 to $850. Then you buy it again.
On the surface: A thin plastic film (PTFE). The chemical family behind it, PFAS, is now being banned state by state.
Sticks?: Nothing, for 3 months. Then everything. Mine turned at week 11.
Lasts: Peeled at month 7 on the hybrid. Customers: 3 weeks to 3 years.
Weight and care: Light. But no metal, no high heat, no dishwasher. You cook for the pan.
Aftertaste: Black flecks in the eggs. That's how this whole thing started.

"Lifetime warranty does not cover sticking issues."Daniel, HexClad customer, after 6 months

3.1/10

Verdict: A pan with a subscription fee.

2 of 5 · Tested 14 months

Ceramic: nonstick with better PR

Ceramic coated pan, stained and blackened after six months

Sold as the clean one. Same deal as nonstick, shorter fuse.

Price: $40 to $195 a pan. Customers report up to $1,600 for sets.
On the surface: A sprayed-on ceramic coating. Different film, still a film.
Sticks?: Best release on this page on day one. Gone by month four.
Lasts: Six months on mine before it went black and stayed black.
Weight and care: Light. Hand wash, low heat, wood only. I babied it. It died anyway.
Aftertaste: Customers report chips and a nasty flavour once it turns.

"After about 6 months the nonstick coating wore off... So I don't believe it was user error."Ceramic pan owner, Minimalist Baker comments

3.4/10

Verdict: Pretty for one season.

3 of 5 · Tested 14 months

Stainless: honest, heavy, hates eggs

Stainless pan, browned surface after one fry, magnet stuck to it

The chef's answer, and I respect it. It's on my line at the restaurant. At home, at 7am, it's a different pan.

Price: $100 to $200 for a good tri-ply pan. You buy it once. Fair.
On the surface: Bare steel, no coating. Credit where due. A 2013 study did measure nickel and chromium moving into tomato sauce cooked in it.
Sticks?: Eggs weld on unless you've done it 10,000 times. I have. My wife hasn't.
Lasts: Forever. Best thing about it.
Weight and care: Around 3 lbs for a 12-inch. Scouring powder after every fry. Rainbow stains you never fully get off.
Aftertaste: A metallic note on long tomato and wine braises.

"Stainless steel is a classic for hot cooking but it sticks and one has to know when and how to use one."Home cook, Parrot Forum

6.1/10

Verdict: Buy it if you like scrubbing.

4 of 5 · Tested 14 months

Cast iron: great pan, terrible roommate

Rusty cast iron skillet lifted from the stove

The one your grandma swears by. She's not wrong: no coating. She also had stronger wrists and more patience than you.

Price: $30 to $60. Cheapest pan on this page that lasts.
On the surface: Bare iron plus "seasoning," a layer of baked-on oil. A layer you have to rebuild yourself.
Sticks?: Seasoned, eggs are fine. One tomato sauce strips it and you start over.
Lasts: Forever, if nobody leaves it in the sink. Somebody always does.
Weight and care: About 8 lbs empty. No dishwasher, no soaking, oil it after every wash. Rusts if you look at it wet.
Aftertaste: Acid pulls iron out of the pan. My wine braise tasted like a coin.

"We get the most use out of our cast iron skillet. After they are aged properly... a bit of cooking spray and they are essentially non-stick."Home cook, Parrot Forum

6.6/10

Verdict: If you have the wrists and the routine.

The pattern: every pan gave me one of two deals

Deal one: a layer. Nonstick, ceramic, seasoning. A layer doesn't wear out. It wears away. Into the food, the sponge, the trash. That's why month one is a dream and month three is a divorce.

Deal two: bare metal that fights back. Stainless and cast iron last forever, and you pay for it every night. Weight. Scrubbing. Rust. Eggs welded on.

You didn't ruin those pans. You just picked one of the two deals.

Coated pan cross-section versus titanium cross-section

What I wanted was deal two without the fight. Bare metal, no layer, light, nothing that reacts with a tomato. On paper, that's titanium.

5 of 5 · The pans that say titanium

Titanium: the right idea, mostly fake

Five labelled titanium pans with a fridge magnet test

Brand	What I found	Magnet
HexClad 4.1/10	Shows up in every titanium search. 0% titanium.	FAIL
Our Place Titanium Pro 3.8/10	It's in the name. That's mostly where it lives. Coated surface.	FAIL
Siraat 2.2/10	A customer XRF-tested his: stainless steel 321 on the cooking surface.	FAIL
Taima 4.6/10	Closest to real. Handles loosen weekly, refunds take 8+ months.	PASS
Taiko 9.4/10	Passed this, and everything else. Keep reading.	PASS

Wade's pick · The one that passed

Taiko: the only pan still on my stove

I expected another Taima. Same look, same "100% titanium" claim, same brand you've never heard of. So I tested it harder than the rest.

Magnet test. The magnet slid off like glass. Siraat: stuck flat.
Cut test. Hacksaw through one pan: titanium on the cooking side, no film, no paint line.
Sticking. Cold and dry, yes. Same as the stainless and cast iron above. Heat it 30 seconds on medium, one teaspoon of oil, then the egg. It slides like it's on wet ice, on day 1,000 like day 1, because there's nothing on the pan that can wear off.
Weight and care. Lighter than my stainless. Nowhere near cast iron. Dishwasher, steel wool, metal spatula. No seasoning, no rust, no scouring powder.
Taste. Nothing. No coating to chip, no iron pulled into the sauce, no metallic tang on a 4-hour wine braise.
Guarantee. 25 years. Every nonstick "lifetime warranty" has a footnote about sticking. This one doesn't need it.
Reviews. 4 stars on Trustpilot, the highest of any titanium brand here, with over 1,244 five-star reviews. The 1-stars are about shipping times, not the pan.

What Taiko owners say

"The eggs slid around like they were on wet ice."

Taiko customer

"I used less than a tablespoon of avocado oil and the omelet I made was basically sitting on an air hockey table."

Taiko customer

"Cleaning takes less time than the cooking itself."

Taiko customer, translated from Dutch

The catch

It's not on Amazon. You buy from Taiko or you don't. If that's a dealbreaker, buy another $20 nonstick pan and set a reminder for next year.

Taiko HammerCraft Pan

$99.95restock sale, up to 50% off

✓ Less than one good stainless pan
✓ 6-piece bundle costs less than a $699 hybrid nonstick set
✓ 25-year warranty · Free shipping · 30-day returns

Check today's restock price

Once the restock sells out, the pricing doesn't come back.

99 pans in my garage. One on my stove.

The Taiko has been on my stove for 14 months and it looks like the day it arrived. The cast iron went to my brother-in-law. He's welcome to it.

Buy the pan your grandkids will fight over. Or buy another coated one and I'll see you back here next year.

Shop the Taiko Restock Sale

25-year warranty. Free shipping. Not sold on Amazon.

Wade Merritt owns Merritt's Steakhouse in Fort Worth. Two-time Texas Steakhouse of the Year, 31 years behind a grill. He writes about the gear that survives his kitchen.